Foo Fighters frontman Dave Grohl has backed a campaign to overturn a council ban on a teenage heavy metal band practising in their garage – by writing to a Cornish council.

The US rocker leapt to the defence of Black Leaves Of Envy after their local council put in place strict noise restrictions following complaints from neighbours.

The 30-40 decibel restriction, which Grohl compared to ‘the level of a dishwasher at 15 meters distance’, means the band will have to stop practising in a family garage.

The Black Leaves of Envy were told by Cornwall Council that they had to rehearse more quietly in their garage after a complaint from a neighbour

Cerys Plenty, 17, her brother Dylan, 15, and friends Adam Jones, 17, and Lewis Cunningham, 15, were said to be making too much noise in the Plenty’s family garage.

But the group says they have just one immediate neighbour in Praa Sands, Cornwall, who hasn’t complained and the next nearest live a field away.


The former Nirvana drummer penned an open letter to Cornwall Council after the father of two of the band members contacted him, urging the authority to ‘reconsider the restrictions’.


In the letter shared with the band’s 2.35 million Twitter followers, he wrote: ‘Like many musicians, I started in a garage in my neighbourhood. Together with my friends, my adolescent years were made better by playing music with others.

‘Music is not only a healthy pastime, it is a wonderful, creative outlet for kids, and fosters a sense of community necessary to the emotional and social development of any child.’

Appearing on BBC Radio Cornwall, Black Leaves Of Envy member Cerys Plenty said: ‘We were all pretty overwhelmed and so grateful.

‘We never expected a response from them, let alone on such a scale, in so much of our defence. It’s pretty phenomenal’.

Her father, Andrew Plenty, said: ‘It’s one of those dad things, that you kind of have an idea … I was sat there after I’d spoken to the council, very frustrated, composed the letter, emailed it through a contact and sent on via mail.

‘I didn’t think I’d hear anything of it, but, lo and behold, a week later a representative of the Foo Fighters contacted me.’

In a statement read out over the radio, the council said it was investigating the complaint.

‘The law regarding statutory noise nuisance is based on what is reasonable, and it may be that certain activities such as the regular playing of loud music are not appropriate in a residential area,’ the local authority said.

‘The council is legally required to investigate once it has received a complaint about noise. We have not told the band to stop playing but have, however, advised that the sound levels are currently too high.’

It suggested installing sound-proofing and restricting practice times.

Grohl also wrote to the band with advice about sound-proofing a practice area, suggesting the use of sand, gym mats and drywall.

The band said they had been warned they could be fined £5,000 if they breached the noise restriction.

One Black Leaves Of Envy member said he was upset that neighbours had not spoken to the band in person.

‘We aren’t really scary people,’ he said.

‘I mean, the music is obviously quite heavy, but we’re all just normal people.’

Facebook Comments

About the Author

Brent Lindeque is the founder and editor in charge at Good Things Guy.

Recognised as one of the Mail and Guardian’s Top 200 Young South African’s as well as a Primedia LeadSA Hero, Brent is a change maker, thought leader, radio host, foodie, vlogger, writer and all round good guy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *