When South Africans spot a “cultural crime”, we don’t just sit back—we rally, roast, and reclaim with the kind of humour only we can muster. And thanks to a viral TikTok, the nation is now hilariously taking on Americans who dared to “steal” our Milk Tart.
Global (11 November 2024) – Ah, TikTok – the glorious platform where South Africans have proven time and again that when it comes to the comment section, we are unmatched. Whether it’s correcting someone’s pronunciation of “Rooibos”, standing up for Tyla or fiercely defending biltong against the dried-beef pretenders of the world, our collective wit knows no bounds.
And now, the focus of our national pride has turned to… Milk Tart.
Recently, a TikTok by Thabo Baloyi went viral, throwing down the gauntlet with an accusation.
“Americans are stealing our Milk Tart!” His rant was nothing short of brilliant, as he declared, “We’ve gladly given away Elon Musk, Charlize Theron, and even nearly Nelson Mandela’s hearing aid… but it’s never enough for some people.”
And the alleged thief? A dish known as Desperation Pie, which apparently even Martha Stewart has dared to include in her recipe collection.
@thabo_baloyi_ The Americans have stolen our milk tart… #SouthAfrica #SouthAfricans #Milktart ♬ original sound – Thabo Baloyi
As word spread, South Africans did what we do best – took to the internet in full force. Martha Stewart’s video recipe for Desperation Pie became the battlefield where proud bakers and Milk Tart lovers left comments defending our cultural heritage with the kind of sharp humour that deserves its own trophy.
@marthastewartliving The official state pie of Indiana, sugar cream is a regional specialty. It has a rich vanilla custard filling inside a buttery pastry crust. Get the recipe at the link in our bio. #marthastewart #pie #recipe #dessert ♬ original sound – Martha Stewart
Some comments were too colourful to share (this is a family-friendly space, after all), but here are a few gems:
Related Story
“Sounds the call to come together!”
“Desperation Pie? Ma’am, please don’t disrespect us like that.”
“Milk Tart from TEMU.”
“Moenie my mal maak nie!”
It’s safe to say South Africans were not about to let this one go without a fight.
So, what’s the deal? Did America steal our Milk Tart?
Well, Desperation Pie, like Milk Tart, is a custard pie. Both are simple desserts with a short list of ingredients designed to be affordable and comforting. However, there are key differences. Milk Tart has a creamy, spiced custard filling with a cinnamon topping, while Desperation Pie uses a more set custard with vinegar or buttermilk for tang. (Yes, vinegar – let’s not dwell on that.)
Historically speaking, both desserts are born from resourcefulness. Milk tart traces back to South Africa’s Dutch settlers in the 17th century, inspired by European custard tarts but adapted with local ingredients. Desperation Pie, on the other hand, became popular in America during the Great Depression when ingredients were scarce. So, while they share similarities, it’s safe to say milk tart came first – and proudly so.
Here’s the best part though, this isn’t really about who made it first. It’s about how food brings us together and sparks joy, even in the most unexpected ways. Thabo’s TikTok has given us another reason to laugh and connect, reminding us that no matter what happens, South Africans know how to rally, defend, and celebrate the things we hold dear.
But some of those comments though. LOL.
by 