In a landmark court case, Cape of Good Hope SPCA Chief Inspector Jaco Pieterse emerged victorious after challenging a pastor’s disturbing social media post mocking a dead animal, highlighting the organisation’s unwavering commitment to animal welfare and dignity.
South Africa (01 September 2023) – In a remarkable victory for animal welfare and dignity, the Cape of Good Hope SPCA Chief Inspector Jaco Pieterse emerged victorious in a landmark court case against a pastor who had posted a disturbing photo on social media.
The case sheds light on the invaluable role that the SPCA plays in safeguarding animals in South Africa.
The incident dates back to September 2019, when Pastor Mark Le Roux decided to use social media to showcase his first kill as a novice hunter. The shocking image featured a fresh buck carcass posed behind the steering wheel of his bakkie, accompanied by Le Roux mimicking the lifeless animal. Even more disturbing was his caption, in which he questioned whether his actions had sexually aroused him, using explicit language.
The post drew widespread condemnation, with many individuals, including Chief Inspector Jaco Pieterse, expressing their shock and disbelief at the insensitivity and cruelty displayed by Le Roux. Pieterse’s comment, questioning the mental state of someone who would mock a dead animal and admit to deriving pleasure from killing it, led to a legal battle between the two.
Le Roux, who held a master’s degree in theology, alleged defamation and reputational damage amounting to R200,000 against Pieterse. He claimed that Pieterse’s comments had led to career setbacks, including being shunned by his church and losing the trust of a section of the community he had previously served. During the court proceedings, Le Roux attempted to justify his actions by asserting that humans have dominion over animals. However, this argument was promptly challenged, highlighting the glaring contradiction between his claims of care and his disrespectful and degrading behaviour towards the deceased animal.
Advocate Quintin Steyn, representing Chief Inspector Jaco Pieterse, passionately defended his client’s comments, emphasising the importance of animal welfare and freedom of speech. Steyn reminded the court that all members of society are responsible for upholding standards of animal welfare and treating animals with dignity and respect.
In a decisive victory for animal welfare, the court ruled in favour of Pieterse, dismissing Le Roux’s case and awarding costs. The judgment affirmed the principle that mocking and disrespecting animals in any form is unacceptable and that the duty to protect and uphold the dignity of animals transcends personal opinions.
The Cape of Good Hope SPCA, under the leadership of Chief Inspector Jaco Pieterse, remains dedicated to its mission of advocating for animals and ensuring their well-being. The organisation expressed gratitude to Advocate Quintin Steyn and Wright Attorneys Inc. for providing pro bono legal representation, demonstrating their commitment to this important cause.
Pieterse highlighted the significance of the outcome, stating, “This was a win for animal welfare and for the dignity of all animals.”
Related Story
The victory not only holds individuals accountable for their actions but also reinforces the critical role that organisations like the SPCA play in safeguarding animals’ rights and promoting a compassionate and ethical society.
As South Africa continues to strive for a society that respects and values all creatures, the SPCA remains a beacon of hope, advocating for animals and championing their rights in the face of adversity. The case serves as a reminder that cruelty and disrespect towards animals will not be tolerated and that organisations like the SPCA are steadfast defenders of those who cannot speak for themselves.
by 